RWC 2011 Semi Finals: Who Says History Never Repeats?

“History never repeats” or so goes the iconic song by Kiwi band Split Enz. All New Zealanders will hope that’s not the case for the 2011 Rugby World Cup.

And there’s a real sesne of deja vu when it comes to the final four. The same teams who made the semi finals of the innagural 1987 tournament in NZ are through again; only this time they’re matching up differently with Wales taking on France and New Zealand doing battle with Australia.

And, to quote another kiwi band – Flight of the Conchords – it’s really “business time” in the tournament now.

Based on form no one really expected the four teams we have left. Certainly our predictions for the RWC 2011 quarter finals were terrible. We only got the New Zealand result correct. Our scoreline was pretty close in that match but we’re the first to admit it was a much closer match than the final score of 33-10 suggested.

For the record, these were our predictions and the actual results:

Ireland 21 v Wales 18 – ACTUAL: 10-22

England 20 v France 11 – ACTUAL: 12-19

South Africa 19 v Australia 14 – ACTUAL: 9-11

New Zealand 37 v Argentina 9 – ACTUAL 33-10

So the All Blacks have made it further than the 2007 Rugby World Cup, much to the relief of the home nation fans. Up next are neighbours and fierce rivals, Australia who the Kiwis have never beaten in the two times they’ve played them at a RWC.

There’s been every other piece of history dug up to suggest who will or won’t win this tournamnet as well. The impressive Eden Park record is being suggested as a trump card for the All Blacks along with the fact no team has lost a match in the tournament and gone on to win it. Since the All Blacks are the only undefeated team left it bodes well.

Countering this, no team has won the tournament without beating the current cup holder. Of course NZ didn’t have a chance to beat an existing cup holder in ’87 since it was a brand new tournament. And we didn’t have the opportunity to face the current champions – South Africa – this time either.

No matter, every team will be trying to create their own piece of history. Wales have never made it to a final while France have never won a cup. But we have our eyes firmly on the future and here’s how we think it will go.

Wales 21 v France 16

New Zealand 23 v Australia 16

It’s also worth noting that it’s not just the players matching up. There are some interesting coaching battles too, with three of the four teams having a Kiwi in charge. Only France don’t have a New Zealander at the helm.

Let’s hope the rival Kiwi coaches will play their part in helping Graham Henry and all New Zealanders singing for joy and making the final of RWC 2011. We’d take France in a repeat of the first world cup but most Kiwis will be wishing to see Wales make their first final this time around.

If previous matches are anything to go by the half back and open side flanker will have a massive influence on the result. And all four teams have highly influential players in those positions. Let’s hope Piri Weepu and Richie McCaw are both singing from the same hymn sheet on Sunday.

Game(s) on.

RWC 2011: A Review at the end of pool stages

Dan Carter’s groin is getting most of the headlines in New Zealand…and not for the usual reasons. The All Blacks star pivot has been invalided out of the tournament; replaced by Manawatu’s Aaron Cruden.

But, the tournament still goes on without him, and the All Blacks haven’t actually lost yet. In fact, they’re still the bookies’ favourites.

You suspect they’ll be too strong for a battered and old Argentina side who snuck through thanks to a late win over Scotland. But the other quarter finals are anyone’s to win or lose with some mouth watering match ups in store.

As looked likely after Ireland beat Austrlia in the pool, it has proven to be taste of the Four Nations that starts next year on one side of the draw with four of the six nations sides on the other. Only one thing certain at this stage…it will be a Southern vs Northern hemisphere final.

The quarter finals line up like this…and here are our predictions:

Ireland 21 v Wales 18

England 20 v France 11

South Africa 19 v Australia 14

New Zealand 37 v Argentina 9

We didn’t pick the Irish upset over the Wallabies but did pretty well in our RWC 2011 predictions in terms of results and scores. The other results we got wrong were the Canuks beating the Tongans and drawing with Japan and the Tongans beating France. We also called the Argentina v Scotland match in favour of the Scots and picked Samoa to beat the Welsh.

Still, 42 matches out of 48 wasn’t a bad result. For the record, here are our predictions and the actual results:

Pool A

NZ  33 v Tonga 14 — actual 41-10

France 42 v Japan 18 — actual 47-21

Tonga 25 v Canada 14 — actual 20-25 (WRONG)

NZ 68 v Japan 9 — actual 83-7

France 32 v Canada 14 — actual 46 – 19

Tonga 21 v Japan 15 — actual 31-18

NZ 31 v France 16 — actual 37-17

Canada 14 v Japan 23 — actual 23-23 (WRONG)

France 35 v Tonga 18 — actual 14-19 (WRONG)

NZ 74 v Canada 9 — actual 79-15

Pool B

Scotland 31 v Romania 6 — actual 34-24

Argentina 9 v England 19 — actual 9-13

Scotland 20 v Georgia 11 — actual 15-6

Argentina 33 v Romania 6 — actual 43-8

England 33 v Georgia 9 — actual 41-10

England 42 v Romania 3 — actual 67-3

Argentina 9 v Scotland 15 — actual 13-12 (WRONG)

Georgia 21 v Romania 11 — actual 25-9

England 20 v Scotland 9 — actual 16-12

Argentina 21 v Georgia 9 — actual 25-7

Pool C

Australia 28 v Italy 14 — actual 32-6

Ireland 31 v 9 USA — actual 22-10

Russia 9 v USA 19 — actual 6-13

Australia 26 v Ireland 17 — actual 6-15 (WRONG)

Italy 32 v Russia 6 — actual 53-17

Australia 43 v USA 6 — actual 67-5

Ireland 33 v Russia 3 — actual 62-12

Italy 26 v USA 13 — actual 27-10

Australia 45 v Russia 6 — actual 68-22

Ireland 24 v Italy 12 — actual 36-6

Pool D

Fiji 37 v Namibia 8 — actual 49-25

South Africa 26 v Wales 18 — actual 17-16

Samoa 37 v Namibia 3 — actual 49-12

South Africa 38 v Fiji 23 — actual 49-3

Wales 24 v Samoa 27 — actual 17-10 (WRONG)

South Africa 52 v Namibia – actual 87-0

Fiji 13 v Samoa 25 — actual 7-27

Wales 47 v Namibia 6 — actual 81-7

24 South Africa v Samoa 18 — actual 13-5

26 Wales v Fiji 16 — actual 66-0

The tier two nations, or so called minows, showed a real improvement over previous tournaments. And if it hadn’t been for the unfavourable and very unfair draw they received you can be sure there would have been more upsets. Let’s hope there’s more fairness and transparency in future tournaments to even the playing field.

But for now it’s onwards and upwards into the knockout stages…