RWC 2011: A Review at the end of pool stages

Dan Carter’s groin is getting most of the headlines in New Zealand…and not for the usual reasons. The All Blacks star pivot has been invalided out of the tournament; replaced by Manawatu’s Aaron Cruden.

But, the tournament still goes on without him, and the All Blacks haven’t actually lost yet. In fact, they’re still the bookies’ favourites.

You suspect they’ll be too strong for a battered and old Argentina side who snuck through thanks to a late win over Scotland. But the other quarter finals are anyone’s to win or lose with some mouth watering match ups in store.

As looked likely after Ireland beat Austrlia in the pool, it has proven to be taste of the Four Nations that starts next year on one side of the draw with four of the six nations sides on the other. Only one thing certain at this stage…it will be a Southern vs Northern hemisphere final.

The quarter finals line up like this…and here are our predictions:

Ireland 21 v Wales 18

England 20 v France 11

South Africa 19 v Australia 14

New Zealand 37 v Argentina 9

We didn’t pick the Irish upset over the Wallabies but did pretty well in our RWC 2011 predictions in terms of results and scores. The other results we got wrong were the Canuks beating the Tongans and drawing with Japan and the Tongans beating France. We also called the Argentina v Scotland match in favour of the Scots and picked Samoa to beat the Welsh.

Still, 42 matches out of 48 wasn’t a bad result. For the record, here are our predictions and the actual results:

Pool A

NZ  33 v Tonga 14 — actual 41-10

France 42 v Japan 18 — actual 47-21

Tonga 25 v Canada 14 — actual 20-25 (WRONG)

NZ 68 v Japan 9 — actual 83-7

France 32 v Canada 14 — actual 46 – 19

Tonga 21 v Japan 15 — actual 31-18

NZ 31 v France 16 — actual 37-17

Canada 14 v Japan 23 — actual 23-23 (WRONG)

France 35 v Tonga 18 — actual 14-19 (WRONG)

NZ 74 v Canada 9 — actual 79-15

Pool B

Scotland 31 v Romania 6 — actual 34-24

Argentina 9 v England 19 — actual 9-13

Scotland 20 v Georgia 11 — actual 15-6

Argentina 33 v Romania 6 — actual 43-8

England 33 v Georgia 9 — actual 41-10

England 42 v Romania 3 — actual 67-3

Argentina 9 v Scotland 15 — actual 13-12 (WRONG)

Georgia 21 v Romania 11 — actual 25-9

England 20 v Scotland 9 — actual 16-12

Argentina 21 v Georgia 9 — actual 25-7

Pool C

Australia 28 v Italy 14 — actual 32-6

Ireland 31 v 9 USA — actual 22-10

Russia 9 v USA 19 — actual 6-13

Australia 26 v Ireland 17 — actual 6-15 (WRONG)

Italy 32 v Russia 6 — actual 53-17

Australia 43 v USA 6 — actual 67-5

Ireland 33 v Russia 3 — actual 62-12

Italy 26 v USA 13 — actual 27-10

Australia 45 v Russia 6 — actual 68-22

Ireland 24 v Italy 12 — actual 36-6

Pool D

Fiji 37 v Namibia 8 — actual 49-25

South Africa 26 v Wales 18 — actual 17-16

Samoa 37 v Namibia 3 — actual 49-12

South Africa 38 v Fiji 23 — actual 49-3

Wales 24 v Samoa 27 — actual 17-10 (WRONG)

South Africa 52 v Namibia – actual 87-0

Fiji 13 v Samoa 25 — actual 7-27

Wales 47 v Namibia 6 — actual 81-7

24 South Africa v Samoa 18 — actual 13-5

26 Wales v Fiji 16 — actual 66-0

The tier two nations, or so called minows, showed a real improvement over previous tournaments. And if it hadn’t been for the unfavourable and very unfair draw they received you can be sure there would have been more upsets. Let’s hope there’s more fairness and transparency in future tournaments to even the playing field.

But for now it’s onwards and upwards into the knockout stages…

All Blacks lose last Tri Nations to Wallabies but it’s not time to panic

The All Blacks lost the final Tri Nations match 25-20 to the Wallabies today. The Australian team will delight in being the last team to hold the trophy before Argentina join next year for some much needed variety in what will become the Four Nations Rugby Tournament.

With two consecutive loses, after falling to a full strength Springboks in South Africa last weekend, there will be some panic. But that will mostly be from the media and some public, no doubt dishing up the term “chokers” like candy. But I don’t think the players or management will be quite so worried.

O.K, they wouldn’t have planned to lose this match. But you have to figure they can’t win them all…and if you’re going to drop a game this one was preferable to a small tournament about to start in under two weeks.

The All Blacks can, and I think will, still win the Rugby World Cup. Here’s why. They played poorly last night but were able to change tactics mid match, mount a serious comeback and almost win the match.

And they did it with Dan Carter having a pretty poor match (shocking by his standards in fact) and without two of our most under rated but key, players – Jerome Kaino and Kieran Read.

Kaino was left out due to the birth of a son and Read left the field injured after 10 minutes. If Read is fit, and with Kaino’s serious muscle to beef up the forwards, the All Blacks will get back to doing what they do best – wining the breakdown for quick ball on attack and slow ball to defend.

Adam Thompson also went off injured but looked out of his depth prior to that. Balancing that was Victor Veto’s impressive display. He’ll  make for a great backup who can play all three lose forward positions if needed.

Israel Dagg has to come into consideration too. If it’s not to start at fullback surely his impact is needed on the bench or even at wing.

The loss will hurt, no doubt. Richie McCaw will be hearing the cocky sledging of Quade Cooper in his nightmares. But they’re be stronger and wiser for this loss. And with a few personal changes Richie will have the last laugh when he holds the Web Ellis trophy aloft in October.

So, no, it’s not panic stations, the All Blacks aren’t choking. It was just a slight obstacle on the way to the big prize.

Richie McCaw

Name: Richard Hugh (Richie) McCaw

Born: 31 December 1980 in Oamaru, North Otago

Height: 6’2″

Weight: 100 kg

Position: loose forward, mostly openside flanker

Club Team:

Representative Teams: Caterbury, Crusdaders, All Blacks

Tries:

Goals:

Drop Goals:

Points:

Bio: